TTS AAR: Later Carthaginians versus Lancastrians: Take Two

Having been hammered fairly quickly in our first game, there was still time for my Carthaginians to fight Dillon’s Wars of the Roses Lancastrians again.

Although the terrain was very different, we both deployed in a similar fashion to our last encounter and, again, my cavalry attempted an outflanking manouevre on the left.

The Lancastrians responded with a magnificent advance in echelon which effectively neutralised my flank attack, which meant that it looked as if my troops were going to have to do things the hard way!

An advance in echelon has one weak point, and I was able to get a unit of veteran Celtic cavalry to charge exactly where they needed to in order to crack the Lancastrian position but, as with the last game, the cards refused to give me any sort of useful result, not even a disorder, and the moment of opportunity rapidly passed!

On the right flank, however, the Carthaginian veteran infantry, equipped as Roman legionaries, were doing well. A pilum killed an enemy general in the opening charge and, despite attacking uphill and the nasty shock of an extra Billmen Flank Attack unit suddenly appearing, the Vets managed to kill or drive back everything in their reach, and were eventually in a position to threaten the enemy camp, having taken about half of the Lancastrian victory medals on their own.

Elsewhere, although I’d failed to crack the Lancastrian formation with my cavalry, I was gradually grinding them down on the left. Remember that after all the good work from the Carthaginian Vets, all I needed to do was gain five coins (2.5 units) and I was well on the way to doing so.

Then disaster struck!

It started with losing the cavalry that had tried to pry open the Lancastrian position, and their general, to another bi-polar run of attack/save cards: that’s five Aces you can see, including three consecutively, leaving me down four coins.

Then my elephants, after getting into a prime position to stomp some Lancastrian infantry from the flank, failed to do so as the Aces kept coming. The elephants and their general then died as the unit to their flank neatly pivoted, attacked, and drove them from the table. That’s down another three coins.

Finally, Dillon managed to sneak his one unit of cavalry through my lines and take one of my camps: another three coins gone! And look at his cards! An eight to move into range, and then a ten to take the camp!

Then, finally, my last coin and the game disappearing as a unit of Numidian light cavalry failed to evade Lancastrian Billmen and was hit and killed.

Even Dillon acknowledged my pain. As he said afterwards:

I've never won 12-0 and never won two TtS! games in a row. The second was my Man U v Bayern Munich event. About half my units were disordered at the end but all the card luck was with me for the last 2 or 3 moves. You was well and truely robbed!

That’s another deck of cards heading for cremation pour encorager les autres, and the start of a big sulk from me!

TTS AAR: Later Carthaginians versus Wars of the Roses

Time to get my newly painted Carthaginians onto the tabletop for the first time, with my opponent being friend Dillon and his Wars of the Roses Lancastrian figures: an army comprised almost solely of Billmen with extra Longbow missile weapons. I had a feeling that this was not going to be easy!

Ed.’s Note: as the figures for the Carthaginian command and Heroes haven’t arrived yet, I proxied them with Celtic alternatives. That’s why you’ll see lots of them on the table!

The game began well: winning the scouting, I then used the This Way Effendi strategum to push one of Dillon’s commands off the table which, along with his Lost stratagem, meant that I started the action with five of Dillon’s eleven medals already in my hands.

As the Lancastrians had used their mounted infantry bonuses to push their main battle line forward already, I began my first turn by pushing the Carthaginian veteran infantry (the Vets) and my mercenary Celts forward as fast as possible, hoping to score a quick win by taking the rest of Dillon’s victory medals before he could bring any of his missing units back onto the table.

At the same time, I sent my mounted command down the left side of the battlefield looking to outflank the Lancastrian main battle line.

This worked quite nicely, with some of the Vets in a position to get stuck in immediately the next turn began, and the Numidian light horse reaching deep into enemy territory. Unfortunately, the Lancastrian line then opened fire with their longbows and, misere de misere, killed a unit of Numidian horse, my only unit of slingers and one of my generals: that’s four of my own victory medals, one third of my total, lost to longbow fire on the first turn!

This was not good, but compensated for by the fact that my Vets then disordered two of the three Billmen units in front of them, and were thus poised to shatter the Lancastrian left flank.

Unfortunately, however, the enemy Lost unit then turned up: another unit of Billmen right on my baseline!

No matter: if the Vets could, as they were perfectly positioned to do, destroy the Billmen command in front of them, then the game would just about be mine, as the Vets could then turn and either go for the enemy camp or roll up the enemy line.

I also managed to get one of my cavalry units across to threaten the flank of the Lost Billmen: a bit of luck with the cards and they would soon be mullered too!

The cards, however, had obviously been offended by my hubris. Looking at the Vets’ attacks on the Billmen on the left, my cavalry’s attacks on the flank of the Lost Billmen and various other “how can you miss” opportunities, I then proceeded to pull eleven (yes, eleven) attack cards in a row with nothing higher than a five! That’s a 0.022% (or 1 in 4532) chance of that happening!

And I lost the elephant to counter-attack. And my Vets pulled a couple of Aces for activation..

This reprieve allowed the Lancastrians time to recover and develop their own attack down my left flank, now empty as all my Numidian light cavalry had died. This allowed one of their Billmen units to take one of my camps and my last three coins!

Well that had been a 12-0 drubbing for the Carthaginians, who had gone from a great opening tactical position to being wiped out for a duck soley (in my humble opinion) because the cards had decided that that was going to happen. Still, at least Dillon was happy. As he said: “I’ve never won 12-0 before”!

Enough Carthaginians To Field An Army

Regular visitors will remember that, given I already have plenty of Celts, I started building Carthaginians as a quick way to get another 28mm army ready for the tabletop.

Next off the production line were the Citizen Infantry, elephants, and Numidian light cavalry.

The Carthaginian Citizen Infantry hit the painting table courtesy of a 60th birthday present from my other (and much better) half, IIRC the first time she has ever actually bought me figures! One packet from Victrix, along with two sets of decals for their shields, gave me enough to build two units for To The Strongest.

These were really easy to build and paint, and I’m especially pleased with the way the shields came out. I used the new pre-punched shield decals from Little Big Man Studios via Victrix and I am completely sold on them. No more fiddly cutting out of tiny designs: these just push out with your thumb and, as you can see, they are just the right size. Why didn’t we have these years ago? I won’t buy anything else from now on!

Next up were two elephant bases, all models also from Victrix:

I was a bit concerned that these would be difficult to build and paint, but they were really easy to do. I didn’t even need any instructions!

I built and painted the following elements separately: the elephant itself, the howdah, and the three crew figures (the two “lights” on the base are spare figures from the other Carthaginian sets I’ve already finished). All very straightforward, even the decals, which look complicated, but aren’t, especially as they were also pre-punched (much love to Victrix/LBMS!).

With the elephants, I undercoated in my usual Grey Seer, then used Contrast Basilicum Grey highlighted with a a light grey acrylic for the skin. The ropes are Contrast Gor-Grunta Fur, the tusks an acrylic white over bone. That was it, nothing more. When it came to the decals for the elephants’ blankets, I brush-painted where they would go in a base white acrylic, waited until it was utterly dry, then just placed the decals as usual. Very easy, looks very good.

Almost the same for the howdah. I painted the frame in Contrast red, then painted the front, back and sides in acrylic white and, once utterly dry, applied the decals as usual. I actually couldn’t believe how easy they were to do. The only tricky bits were the insets in the howdahs’ crenellations, but that’s only because I was a bit impatient. If I’d relaxed a bit and made more of an effort to get them placed just right, they would have looked better…but they look pretty good anyway.

The crew were pretty standard, but it’s worth noting that you get three different varieties of crew in the packet, allowing you to morph your elephants into being Carthaginian, Roman, Ptolemaic or Numidian. Just make sure you buy the right decal sheet for the one you want to field.

Highly, highly recommended, and I’m now thinking I might buy another packet of two nellies for those really big games!

Finally, here are the Numidian light cavalry. Again, one packet’s worth:

These were slightly more difficult to build than the other Victrix sets that I have used over the last few years: for some reason, the place where the sprues and the parts join, once clipped, left stubs that slightly interfered with construction, so I often had to go back and re-clip and smooth before glueing. Okay, so I should make sure that everything is smoothly clipped anyway, but I mention it as a caution to those of you who will also buy this excellent set.

I painted the horses in the light palette that I use to clearly differentiate them from the Gallic horses that form the heavier cavalry (they are painted in much darker shades). I didn’t buy shield transfers for these, opting for a painted cowhide look i.e. not actually cowhide, but shields painted to ressenble it. Roman cow colours of course!

So that’s enough “main body” kit done for me to field Carthaginians: now all I need are the officers and heroes etc. And maybe some Ibericans…and some non-Gallic heavy cavalry…and some Balaeric slingers…and some…the list goes on!

TTS AAR: Gauls versus Later Carthaginians

Time for a practice game for the To The Strongest tournament at this year’s Warfare show: what turned out to be an epic clash between my Gauls and Peter’s Later Carthaginians.

I lost the scouting, and watched as Peter predictably deployed with his troops heavily weighted towards one flank.

I had been here before (far too many times!) so I knew that there was only one way forward: send my cavalry on the far left in a wide sweeping movement to attack the Carthaginian right flank, and position my infantry on the right to face forwards and right in order to hold out until the cavalry arrive to help.

The first phase of the game unfolded as expected, with only the appearance of a double Ace draw interfering with my counter-plan:

Although my cavalry made good time on their flanking manouevre, I let my chariots get distracted by a unit of light infantry lurking in the woods on the left: a silly mistake that tied up three times their points value in a pointless exchange of javelins.

Nevertheless, just as the main Carthaginian attack hit my infantry, the cavalry arrived to distract half of the enemy veteran legionaries:

I had managed to blunt Peter’s weight-one-flank strategy, but I was not out of the woods yet, as was proved when the Carthaginians snuck a unit of light cavalry through the, er, woods that were protecting the corner of my position and smashed a unit of warriors from the table.

This was fairly critical, but was fortunately immediately followed by my cavalry finally breaking one of the units of Carthaginian veteran legionaries and ending up perfectly positioned to ride down another.

Unfortunately, the cards then produced my second double Ace of the day, and the Celtic horsemen failed to charge home.

The Carthaginins quickly re-positioned themselves, and a grinding fight began as just about every figure on the table was now committed to the kesselschlacht.

Key to my position were the two warbands that were facing to the right at the bottom of the table: if either of them went, then it was safe to say that the rest of my army would follow.

Somehow they held out, turn after turn, both double-disordered and under constant attack, but obviously determined not to give way, perhaps encouraged by the two chieftains that were with them.

At this stage, the Carthaginians (who had lost a couple of generals) were down to their last two coins, meaning defeat if one more unit routed. I still had something like seven left, but with most of my warbands on two disorders already, one lost unit would almost certainly lead to a cascade of routs that would cost me the game. It was close…very close!

In the end, it was the Carthaginians who gave way first: their cavalry failing to evade when charged in the flank:

A fantastic game of TTS that absolutely came down to the wire. Peter deployed superbly, and it was only by the slimmest of margins that I managed to get my infantry into a position to hold until my cavalry arrived. Even then, if it hadn’t been for the extreme resilience of the two warbands on my right flank, my army would have collapsed in spectacular fashion. The very narrowest of victories for the Gauls!

Victrix Warriors of Carthage

Now my Celts are just about complete, it was time to think about what my next army would be. Looking at the lists, the obvious crossover with the Celts is a Carthaginian army of some kind (Early, Middle or Later), as the Celts that I have just finished would provide all the heavy cavalry and around one third of the infantry needed for Hannibal’s boys.

A quick visit to the Victrix website saw me purchase the Warriors of Carthage pack: an excellent acquisition which, when painted, would provide three units of Libyan light infantry with javelins; one deep unit of mercenary Hoplites; and two units of African spearmen wearing captured Roman armour (“Hannibal’s Veterans”). That’s half the extra infantry I would need all for the princely sum of £35: a bargain at around 57p per figure.

First on the painting table were the Libyan light javelinmen: a very easy paint as they have minimum equipment, especially if you don’t give them shields! I used a 50/50 mix of Contrast Darkoath Flesh and Guilliman Flesh for their skin; and a dark red highlighted, washed and highlighted again for their tunics.

Having painted a few hundred 15mm Hoplites, I was not looking forward to doing the mercenary Greeks, but it turned out that they were almost as easy to do as the Libyan javelinmen. I undercoated in Grey Seer, then painted the panoplies in either white or a linen colour using different techniques to get variety: some were painted with acrylic white over Grey Seer, some with acrylic Wraithbone over Grey Seer, some with Contrast white then highlighted with acrylic white, and some with Contrast Skeleton Horde over Grey Seer. Then, on some of the panoplies, I outlined the seams in a variety of colours.

The flesh was painted as above, with the rest of the figure/equipment done as I would usually do so: Contrast Snakebite Leather for the leather, Wyldwood for the spear shafts etc. The aspis shields were painted on the sprue: undercoated in Grey Seer on the rear and Corax White on the front, then the backs were painted Contrast Wyldwood with the holding-cord picked out in an acrylic leather colour, and the fronts with decals from Little Big Man Studios via Victrix and then edged appropriately. I’m very happy with the result.

The two units of Carthaginian spearmen gave me a few more problems. As most of the figure is effectively chainmail (captured Roman armour) I decided to undercoat in black…which made the chainmail easy but meant that I could not use my belov’d Contrast paints for everything else…which meant painting everything else with the Holy Trinity of basecoat, layer and highlight or, in my case, basecoat and highlight as I always was a heathen…but once I’d got the hang of this retro painting system, building and painting the two units didn’t take too long at all.

The shields were as easy to do as always, but haven’t come out as well as the hoplite shields, above. Not sure why, perhaps it’s something to do with the shield designs or, more likely, something I did differently!

So that’s most of the Carthaginian infantry now done: just a couple of units of non-Roman-armour spearmen and the elephants to do now…and some Numidian cavalry…and all the command bases, casualties and heroes…and maybe some Celtiberians/Scutatoi…the list goes on!

TTS AAR: Britcon Game Four: Venice Abroad versus Middle Carthaginians

Three games down: two wins and one loss. Onto the next: more Carthaginians, this time of the Middle rather than the Late variety and led by that thoroughly nice chap, Mark.

Before I start this report I think it only fair to state two things. The first is that Mark was suffering from the after-effects of a rather nasty shoulder dislocation (no, it wasn’t me): not sleeping and largely unable to use his left arm! And, yes, I did make sure I attacked on the right, shame on me!

Secondly, those of you who follow this blog will know that I am usually plagued by terrible cards. Well, not today. All my terrible cards found their way into Mark’s deck: I’ve only ever seen such a collection of Aces before on my side of the table!

Anyway, with those opening statements out of the way, on to the action.

The Carthaginians outscouted and, after deployment, advanced forward confidently.

On the Carthaginian left was their cavalry: a mass of veteran heavies and lights. My first action was to essay a shot at the lead unit of enemy horse with my crossbowmen and light crossbowmen. Quarrels (the word comes from Old French quarrel (from carré, “square”), referring to the bolt’s square-shaped head) flew across the battlefield and, much to both our surprises, slammed into the enemy unit and cut them down to a man, including their general. The shock of seeing their comrades slain was then too much for the surrounding light cavalry units, who fled the field to bring tales of woe and impending disaster to anyone who would listen!

I’d played four cards and taken six coins…all which I would obviously be paying to my mercenary crossbowmen!

Worse, for Mark, was the fact that my Knights then charged forward (“what’s that coming over the hill…is it a monster?” “No, worse: it’s the Venetian knights!”) and thundered into the remaining enemy horse, lances poised for carnage!

Meanwhile, on the other side of the table, my other Knights were watching the enemy elephants stomp slowly forwards accompanied by the Carthaginian heavy infantry.

My plan was now to avoid fighting on the left until my right hand Knights could turn and roll up the enemy line, and I also moved my main infantry force in the centre forward in order to pin some advancing Celtiberians in place until the Knights were ready.

I needed to keep the Carthaginian right focussed forward as opposed to allowing them to turn to reinforce the centre and left, so was forced to make my Knights a threat even if I wanted them nowhere near the advancing enemy nellies.

This led to some dicey moments for the left hand Knights as Mark’s clever use of the Someone has Blundered card along with my only bad luck of the game left them vulnerable but, for once, they had remembered to put on their proper as opposed to cardboard armour, and they were able to retreat out of danger having done exactly what they were supposed to do.

Meanwhile, my Knights on the right had sorted themselves out and proceeded to carry out the other part of the plan: curling round to hit the Carthaginians’ Celtiberian allies in the flank.

Aided by my infantry advancing out from the camp, it took only a turn or two to take Mark’s remaining coins.

Well that had, from the canal-dweller point of view, been a cracking game!

Mark was so unlucky in that first turn to lose half his cavalry like that, and even more so as that perfectly opened up his flank to my Knights. He might have been able to compensate on the right but, again, just didn’t get the cards to get his men forward fast enough.

As for the Venetians: it was on to the final game and, with three wins out of four, the same as the other leading contenders, a chance for overall victory!

TTS AAR: Britcon Game Three: Venice Abroad versus Later Carthaginians

My final game of day one of this year’s Britcon To The Strongest tournament was against Howard and his Later Carthaginians.

I’d faced these lads before, and they have always been a tough nut to crack, especially with Howard’s propensity to put loads of steep hills onto the tabletop and then hide his light infantry on them: very difficult to winkle out!

I lost the scouting again, so set up in a tight formation weighted towards my left flank, but a slow Carthaginian start gave me the time to readjust for their deployment and establish a more central position as the game began. My plan was to defeat the Carthaginians on the left with most of my army, before turning right to finish off the remainder.

The action duly began on my left flank, where I had rapidly advanced my Knights in an attempt to knock out the Carthaginian and Numidian cavalty there before heading into the centre behind the enemy line.

My first charges were very successful: knocking the Numidians and a unit of cavalry off the table. Unfortunately, I didn’t manage to exploit this initial success, and the Carthaginians were able to bring across reinforcements and stabilise the situation.

This pattern then repeated itself as again my Knights successfully charged forward only to fail to finish the job and let the Carthaginians back into the game…so much so that it looked as if I was about to lose that flank entirely.

Fortunately I managed to bring some reinforcements of my own across and, by the end of the game, the left flank was very much in a tied position, both sides too exhausted to do much more than glare at each other!

Note that that initial unit of veteran Carthaginian legionaries was still standing, as were my Knights on that side: some units prove just impossible to kill!

Meanwhile, on the other side of the table, fearsome amounts of Carthaginians were heading towards my lone command there.

Very quickly, the Carthagians managed to get their cavalry right down onto my baseline, and I now faced the classic problem of trying to defend both front and flank at the same time.

The Venetian Knights are, however, very tough (when, that is, they remember not to put on their cardboard armour!) and that initial flanking position was defended successfully and all seemed to be stabilised on the right, especially as the main body of Carthaginian infantry (nasty veteran javelinmen types) hung back in relative safety on the steep hills that scattered that side of the table.

This couldn’t last for long and, as Howard realised that his right wasn’t going to win the battle on its own, he send the infantry forward, and the situation on my left suddenly got a whole lot more critical.

Althoug helped by a bit of bad luck on Howard’s part, my troops on the right soon found themselves pushed right back to my camp and under extreme potentially game-losing pressure!

All was not lost, however: fighting from behind the walls of my fortified camps (the rather infamous barbed wire!) gives you a major advantage, and my camps remained inviolate.

Both sides were now on their last legs, but the cards were smiling on me for a change and, as both Howard and I ruefully checked how many coins we each had left, my veteran Later Knights (with two heroes from the Tonight We Dine In Hell card I’d played earlier) swung into action and, with a cry of “Venice Forever, whilst they keep paying my wages” they charged forward against the two units of Carthaginian cavalry in front of them.

It’s the Knights on the right that you need to be looking at!

It was, quite frankly, glorious: with both enemy units being dashed from the table along with their accompanying general to give me victory!

These ones!

Well that had been a very close run thing!

If the Knights hadn’t charged when they did, and if my cards hadn’t been good and Howard’s bad, then I doubt that I could have held my camp for that much longer. But they did, and they were, so the game was mine - just!

All my games with Howard were good, but this was particularly so, and a great way of finishing day one of the tournament.

Figures packed away, we headed out to sample the delights of Leicester’s nightlife…

TTS AAR: To The Smallest Game 4: Arab Conquest vs Later Carthaginians

My final game at this year’s To The Smallest competition was an absolutely bonkers affair against other-Rob’s Later Carthaginians.

I say ‘absolutely bonkers’ as I’ve never played a game of To The Strongest quite like it. Seven of the eight Generals that started the game died; I was pulling 10’s out of the pack like there were no lower cards present; victory could have gone to either side in the final stages of the battle ; and the whole 160 point game was over in 45 minutes!

So what actually happened…

First up, Arab mounted infantry and the Take the High Ground” strategem card meant that the two sides started the game really close together:

The first action was on the far left, where Rob had been trying to sneak a unit of massed light cavalry around my flank. Not wanting this to happen, I sent some light camelry in that direction, thinking to intercept the Numidians in a turn or so.

The cards, however, were with me, and pulling a couple of tens in a row meant that I hit the lights in the flank right when they were on the edge of the field.

Although the camels didn’t manage to destroy the Numidians, they did disorder them, and for the rest of the game the two sides knocked seven bells out of each other without either side actually managing to finish off their opponent.

Meanwhile, on the other flank, some more Numidian cavalry had managed to get onto my flank, and despite the fact that they were raw massed lights, eventually managed to wipe out the cavalry command I had stationed there!

This was a bit unfortunate, but the cavalry had managed to take some of the enemy with them, so not a total loss.

Back to the centre, which had neatly divided into two halves as the two battle lines moved together.

Left-of-centre, I had a couple of units of Jund cavalry facing vast numbers of Celtic types - these Carthaginians are a mixed bunch! - but the Jund were on form smashing one warband from the field and moving up to engage the others. My cards had been very good here: lots of tens!

Generals had been dying in droves at this point: Rob had already lost three, and I had lost two, and at two Victory Medals apiece, that can really cut into your cache!

Right of centre, the action developed into a massive infantry melee as deep units of Hoplites and Spearmen smashed into my Warriors (half of them Fanatics).

Disorder markers rained down on the units involved, with the advantage slightly with me as my Fanatics ignored the associated penalty on combat ability.

The luck, however, stayed with me, and a final flurry of ten’s from my infantry (in defence as well as attack) and the death of the last remaining Carthaginians general gave me another five coins and the game.

I had won 16-9, but that didn’t really represent how close the game was. I had taken the last of Rob’s coins with a deep unit and a general going i.e. five coins, so before that, we had been on 11-9 in my favour. If my fanatics had gone (I’d already lost their general!) then the score would have been 11-12 in Rob’s favour with all to play for.

It had been a great game, played at a rapid rate of knots, full of action and much hilarity, especially as one general after another bit the dust. A great way to end the tournament. In the end, I came 6th overall, not bad for two wins and two losses…and it’s always a pleasure to game at Firestorm and to see the TTS crowd again.

Britcon Day Two: Game Four

This was probably my hardest game of the tournament: matched up against Howard’s beautifully painted Later Carthaginians.

This was an epic clash that lasted some 3½ hours and was the only game of mine that was stopped by the umpire rather than coming to its natural conclusion.

Rather than use the set terrain, we had used the rules in the book, allowing me to protect my wings with a couple of pieces of impassable rocks. That meant that I could tie up his three units of heavy cavalry with the Praetorians and Auxilia whilst the rest of my army went for the rest of his.

My plan was for one unit of Legionaries to take out his elephants centre-left, whilst my cavalry took out the rest of his cavalry centre-right and then got round behind and into his camp. Meanwhile, I would hold back his elite pseudo-Legionaries with the rest of my true Legionaries on the right.

As always, no plan survived first contact with the enemy: my Legionaries refused point blank to go after his elephants and my cavalry got blocked in the middle…Howard had some annoying light infantry positioned on steep hills that caused me a lot of grief.

One of the key moments of the game: the equites alares get back to block the carthaginian heavy cavalry

The battle started to sway Howard’s way but, for once, the Roman cavalry were superb. The Equites Alares effectively held the centre on their own, rushing backwards and forwards to force his advancing units to protect their flanks.

At the end of the game it was tied 5:5, but my cavalry, on their last turn, managed to flank charge one of Howard’s units knocking it from the board and thus giving me a 7:5 victory.

TTS AAR: Elephants Swimming in Canals

Back in April this year, friend Peter asked me if I would have a game of To The Strongest with him as a test for one of the armies he was considering taking to the Chalgrove World Championships. Why has it taken me so long to deliver the After Action Report? Well, Peter didn’t want any hint of which armies he might be using to leak to possible opponents, so had slapped a D-Notice on me. Now, however, that he is basking in another victory, he has graciously given permission for the secret files covering our game to be released!

Peter’s test-army was the Venetians, and he had asked if I would use a Later Carthaginian army against them. This would be a real test for the canal-dwellers: a cavalry army against Hannibal’s spear-armed infantry supported by elephants…and on a board with at least some trees on it.

The Venetians: Knights & Lights!

Hannibal’s Brave Boys

Of course, part of the problem with writing an AAR six months after the event is that I can’t actually remember much of how the game played out!

What I do know is that Peter completely wrong-footed me at the start by gaining the initiative and deploying all on the (from my point of view) right side of the table versus my more evenly spread line. This would mean that he could concentrate his army on only a portion of mine, gaining victory there before then turning to polish off the rest. Cunning stuff!

As it happens, however, this didn’t work as, somehow, I managed to get my heavy spearmen moving and across the field to support my by now beleaguered right flank.

My Celtic warriors also refused to give way despite being hit by veteran knights with a general from the front and two units of knights from the rear, joined by two lights, for several turns. Their Celtic cavalry comrades were equally resilient: normal Celtic cavalry convincingly winning a melee against veteran lance-armed later knights supported by lance-wielding mass lights: they killed the knights and drive the lights back without suffering a single hit!

The game developed into a huge melee in the centre of the table, with the action swirling backwards and forwards. Despite my successes, above, my army was starting to look a bit ragged and I could see that a collapse was fairly imminent: there were just too many light units hitting or threatening to hit my flanks.

It was time for a Hail Mary. I had one unit of Celtic horse still undamaged. I could see the Venetian camp (complete with fountain and gondola) in a straight line in front of them, with only some more of those massed lights blocking their way. The Celts charged forward and, with a great run of cards, smashed the light horse out of the way and then thundered into the enemy camp. Three victory medals to the good, the victory was mine!

It had been a cracking game that I had won through good luck and by the very thinnest of margins. As Peter said afterwards, “if it wasn’t for your extended gallop into my camp I would have won in my turn”. My only reply is, obviously, and with apologies to the Spartans: "If..."!

Here’s the full pictorial story of the battle: